Apple’s new touchscreen MacBook Pro has failed to convince the author of this opinion piece, despite the appeal of its OLED display. The model, which Apple calls the “PROLED XDR display,” is presented as offering professionals “a whole new way to interact with their content.”
The criticism focuses on the ergonomics of using a touchscreen laptop for extended periods. Apple highlights drawing directly across the display and playing software instruments on screen, but the author argues that holding the arms out toward a laptop would quickly become uncomfortable. In this view, touchscreen gestures are either unnecessary or suitable only for brief interactions.
That limited use raises questions about value, particularly because the touchscreen model reportedly costs $400 more than the regular MacBook Pro. The article notes a starting price of $2,899 and a maximum configuration priced at $14,549, while arguing that the OLED panel alone provides the more convincing justification for the premium.
The editorial also takes issue with how Apple explains the feature. John Ternus, Apple’s new CEO, told WIRED that the company reached a point where adding touch would not make the MacBook Pro heavier or thicker, alongside the introduction of its OLED display. The author interprets that reasoning as evidence that the touchscreen was added because it could be included without compromising the product, rather than because it transformed the laptop experience.
Hands-on impressions from others have been more positive. The article acknowledges that some users have described the touchscreen MacBook Pro as natural and pleasant to operate initially. However, it argues that a comfortable first impression does not resolve the longer-term concern about arm fatigue, recalling Steve Jobs’ earlier criticism of touchscreen laptops and the strain caused by keeping an arm extended.
The author concludes that Apple’s implementation feels like an uninspired addition rather than a defining innovation. Although the OLED display is considered worthwhile, the touchscreen itself is portrayed as a feature that may be ignored by many users and does not offer a sufficiently compelling reason to choose this MacBook Pro.
Sources: TechRadar.